Content of Opinions and Controversies in our journal

  • Published in last 1 year
  • In last 2 years
  • In last 3 years
  • All

Please wait a minute...
  • Select all
    |
  • Opinions and Controversies
    HUANG Yan, LIU Yungang, WANG Tao, CAI Chaoming
    South China Geographical Journal. 2026, 4(3): 7-19. https://doi.org/10.20125/j.2097-2245.20250085

    With the rise of tourism geopolitics research,tourism territorialization studies have received increasing attention in recent years. However, existing studies largely rely on specific case analyses and lack systematic theoretical exploration of the mechanisms through which tourism influences territorial processes and produces territorial effects. To address this gap, this article draws on performativity theory to construct a mechanism-based explanatory framework of tourism-performativity-territory, clarifying how tourism affects territorial processes and generates territorial effects. The article de-essentializes territory and argues that tourism is an everyday performative force shaping territorialization.Repetition and citationality are the main mechanisms through which performances produce territorial effects. Diverse actors in complex territorial relational networks continuously cite dominant power norms, repeatedly implement exclusionary, bordering and differentiating performances in tourism practices, and sustainably accumulate facts of ownership and control over time and space, thereby gradually “doing” the power-space effect of territory through long-term accumulation. However, because the structure of territorial networks, multi-actor interactions, and the market logic of tourism affect the implementation and sustainability of specific territorial performances, tourism-induced territorial effects are dynamic and uncertain, requiring continuous maintenance after their generation. The theoretical discussion in this article contributes to research on tourism territorialization, tourism geopolitics, and performativity, and helps enrich academic explanations at the mechanistic level of territorialization.

  • Opinions and Controversies
    WENG Shixiu
    South China Geographical Journal. 2026, 4(3): 20-25. https://doi.org/10.20125/j.2097-2245.20260026

    Tourism territorialization is a key concept for exploring the question of “how power is deployed in tourism space.” If territorialization can be broadly categorized into “deployment territorialization” and “performative territorialization,” then A Performativity Perspective on the Mechanism of Tourism territorialization offers an important exploration of the mechanisms of performative territorialization within the tourism system. Furthermore, the article holds potential contributions for deepening reflections on the distinction between individual territoriality and group/social territoriality, as well as their interconnections, and on the territoriality displayed by different types of tourists in various tourism contexts. Additionally, the performativity theory adopted in the article adds value to expanding perspectives on territoriality research in human geography. Moving forward, research on this theme could consider adopting a tourism systems perspective to expand the connotations and extensions of tourism territorialization, strengthen the analysis of mechanisms related to scale linkage and scale effects, pay attention to the issue of power symmetry among various actors, and, in light of the complexity and diversity of tourism contexts, integrate relevant theories to construct a more comprehensive theoretical spectrum of tourism territorialization.

  • Opinions and Controversies
    WANG Fenglong
    South China Geographical Journal. 2026, 4(3): 26-33. https://doi.org/10.20125/j.2097-2245.20260051

    The discussion by Yan Huang et al. of tourism territorialization from a performativity perspective not only significantly expands research on tourism geography and tourism geopolitics, but also offers valuable insights for into the concept of territory and the theory of territorialization. However, the paper still leaves room for improvement in explaining the specific mechanisms through which performance,tourism, and territoriality are interrelated, as well as in constructing a unified, multi-scalar explanatory framework. Furthermore, because the study primarily takes tourism as its departure point, its theoretical discussion of territorialization is insufficiently developed. To address these limitations, this paper, on the one hand, attempts to supplement several potential mechanisms through which performance drives territorialization. On the other hand, by focusing primarily on deepening understanding of the concept and theory of territory, this paper argues for moving beyond a performativity-based perspective and understanding territory and territorialization through the more fundamental lens of governmentality. As a governing mode or instrument, territory is conditioned by visibility and calculation, and exhibits strategic, variable characteristics shaped by cost-benefit analysis of openness versus closure. While fundamentally subtle enough to incorporate the performativity perspective, the governmentality approach extends the conceptualization of territory and theoretical interpretations of territorialization toward a more universal horizon, thereby better facilitating our understanding of territory as both a technology and an effect.